Blake surprised Carly with an amazing surprise– a hand built jewelry armoire. He designed every drawer and cabinet for all of her things, and even left some options available so she could tell him exactly how she wanted it. In every drawer he hid a surprise, from a gluten-free brownie mix to snack bars.

But the real surprise wasn’t just the armoire. I mean, do you really need your whole family there so they can see something like that? Granted, it’s beautiful and absolutely amazing– but do you think she suspected?

When she finally gets to the bottom drawer (8:05), Blake instructs her to dig around in the drawer because she may have missed what was in there. She hesitantly pulls out the box, and when she opens it she begins to cry. He pulls her to her feet to propose “properly” around 8:25.

What do you think– genuine surprise? All I can say is if I was Carly, I’d expect homemade gifts for everyone anniversary. Does that make me awful?

Emily